Is it a Feature or is it an Experience?

Windows Feature Experience PackWindows Feature Experience Packs are the new type of Windows Update. But what’s the difference? And when you get an update, is it a Feature or is it an Experience? Does anyone know?

The first Windows Feature Experience Pack appeared in mid-2020 in beta form to Windows Insiders and contained two simple features:

  • a built-in screenshot tool, for sniping and pasting selections into a folder.
  • a split keyboard interface for 2-in-1 touch devices that stretches the keyboard across the two screens when a device is in portrait mode. By device we mean the Microsoft Duo, the folding screen phablet-thing that nobody asked for and nobody seems to want.

Experience packs represent Microsoft’s plan for improved upgrades. They’re starting to appear in the regular monthly updates to Windows 10. As best as anyone can define them:

  • they are not related to the core Windows operating system updates and
  • do not include updates to normal Windows apps that are bundled or available in the Microsoft Store.

They are now available to  Windows 10 version 20H2, 19042.662 and later.

They are also classed as ‘Features on Demand’ for Windows 10 and Windows Server, which indicates that they’re an essential part of the operating system. This becomes clearer in the light of Windows 10X. This is a repackaging of  the basic operating system as a foundation layer, with all applications as separate containers.

Windows Paint, for example, is now a feature on demand outside of the ‘core’ Windows OS updates.

‘Foundation-layer-plus-containers’ is the route for developers to update apps without making the rest of the Windows OS unstable. Much stricter use of containers and foundation services could make the ambition of cheap, fast and stable development a reality. But that’s been the case over several development roadmaps for decades, so don’t hang out the flags just yet.

But it does move toward the stable, containerised Windows 10X which looks like becoming the standard operating system build. It’s difficult to know how this aligns with Windows Core OS.

Microsoft has been less than clear about what this new structure and terminology means (surely not?) and have ignored the consumer level. Windows Feature Experience Packs are now appearing in Windows Update without explanation and the average Joe won’t have a clue what they are, whether they need them, why they have them on one device and not on others or what happens if you don’t take them. It’s Windows Update, so ultimately, you don’t get a choice. AJS

2 thoughts on “Is it a Feature or is it an Experience?

  1. logereborn says:

    What a dismal, bullying, exploitative mess Windows has become with Windows 10. Now that they have the huge captive market they simply don’t give a toss about users who only have their system on loan through the beneficence of Microsoft.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s